نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
The rapid advancement of distributed ledger technology (DLT), particularly decentralized identity (DID) systems, has created significant challenges for Iran’s traditional framework governing official documents, which is based on centralized oversight and state-backed authentication. The Iranian legal system, by emphasizing the validity and formal recognition conferred through the execution of documents in official notarial offices under Article 1287 of the Civil Code, as well as the state’s exclusive authority to verify ownership rights under Article 22 of the Law on Registration of Deeds and Real Estate, is structurally at odds with the paradigm of self-sovereign identity (SSI) and the inherently intermediary-free nature of DID systems. The primary objective of this study is to identify the principal legal and jurisprudential (fiqhi) challenges posed by decentralized identity mechanisms within Iran’s official documentation regime and to propose localization and hybridization models capable of reconciling DID with existing statutory frameworks and Shiʿa (Imami) jurisprudential principles. The main research questions concern the incompatibility of DID with fundamental principles of the Registration Law and the Electronic Commerce Law, its conformity with Shiʿa jurisprudential principles and constitutional requirements—particularly Article 152 concerning the preservation of national independence—and the legislative strategies required to develop hybrid models that combine centralized and decentralized elements.The study hypothesizes that, despite its technical advantages and potential to strengthen privacy protection, DID faces substantial barriers within Iran’s current legal framework, particularly in relation to evidentiary shortcomings and uncertainties surrounding civil and criminal liability. Nevertheless, gradual legislative reform and the development of hybrid frameworks, in which sovereign authorities such as the Organization for Registration of Deeds and Properties retain responsibility for initial identity attestation, may facilitate effective legal and technological convergence.
Methodology
This research adopts a foundational analytical-comparative methodology using a descriptive-analytical approach. The data sources include a comprehensive review of Iranian legislation, including the Civil Code, Registration Law, Electronic Commerce Law, civil liability statutes, and cybercrime legislation; international technical standards, particularly those developed by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C); and qualitative analysis of jurisprudential doctrines, including the fiqhī rules of itlāf (direct causation of harm), tasbīb (indirect causation), and the evidentiary foundations of bayyina. A comparative approach is also employed to examine successful international models, including the European Union’s eIDAS framework and Estonia’s digital identity infrastructure, with the aim of identifying models that may be adapted to Iran’s legal and jurisprudential environment.
Findings
The legal and jurisprudential analysis indicates that DID systems, because they do not fully conform to the evidentiary standards and authentication mechanisms recognized in Shiʿa jurisprudence and Iran’s statutory framework governing official documentation, face several core challenges.Conflict with the Principle of the Official Document (Article 1287, Civil Code):Decentralized identity authentication relies on user-controlled identifiers and private keys rather than verification by a notary public. This approach conflicts with the legal definition of an official document under Article 1287 and with the requirements of physical presence and notarized signature under Article 29 of the Law on Notaries Public. From an evidentiary perspective, DID-based instruments currently lack initial probative authority and would likely be treated as private documents by Iranian courts.Ambiguity in Civil and Criminal Liability:The distributed and peer-to-peer architecture of DID complicates the attribution of responsibility in cases of security breaches, such as the compromise of private keys, or technical failures. This uncertainty creates difficulties in applying Article 1 of the Civil Liability Act and the fiqhī principles of itlāf and tasbīb, both of which generally require responsibility to be attributed to a specific individual. Accordingly, a new legal framework for shared or collective liability may be necessary.National Independence and Infrastructure Considerations:Potential dependence on foreign infrastructures and technical standards, including W3C protocols, together with the risk of service disruption arising from international sanctions, may place DID implementation in tension with Article 152 of the Constitution, which requires the preservation of national independence. This concern highlights the need to develop a sovereign national blockchain infrastructure for domestic DID systems.Jurisprudential (Fiqhī) Obstacles:From the perspective of Shiʿa jurisprudence, authentication based exclusively on cryptographic trust may require broader interpretive approaches or advisory religious opinions in order to reconcile DID with the principles of preserving social order (ḥifẓ al-niẓām) and with the evidentiary authority of documents recognized through state-sanctioned bayyina.Potential for Convergence:The comparative analysis suggests that integrating DID with existing domestic systems, such as the Shahkar platform for initial identity verification, and using verifiable credentials (VCs) could allow DID-based instruments to function as “digital official documents,” provided that the Organization for Registration of Deeds and Properties continues to act as the authoritative attestor of decentralized identity.
Conclusion and Recommendations
The study confirms the existence of a paradigmatic tension between legal centralization and technological decentralization. Legal certainty within Iran’s official documentation system remains closely linked to state authority, and the adoption of DID would therefore require a transformative interpretive approach capable of conferring inherent legal validity on digital documents. At the same time, the selective disclosure mechanisms offered by DID, which strengthen privacy protection, are consistent with Article 22 of the Constitution and with Iran’s broader data governance principles.The following legislative and administrative measures are recommended for the localization and integration of DID within the Iranian legal system:Amendment of the Registration Law:Complementary regulations should be enacted to define “official decentralized signatures” and “digital official documents” based on DID/VC identifiers, thereby granting such instruments initial judicial probative authority.Distributed Liability Framework:A legal framework should be established for joint and several liability among users, credential issuers, and the state as the initial verifier in cases of security breaches or resulting harm, in a manner consistent with the Personal Data Protection Bill.Sovereign Infrastructure Development:A national blockchain should be legally recognized and operationalized as an authoritative and sovereign platform for hosting domestic DID identifiers, thereby safeguarding national independence and reducing risks associated with international sanctions.Regulatory Sandbox:A controlled regulatory sandbox should be established to pilot DID-based registration and authentication services and to reduce the risk of subsequent judicial invalidation.Judicial and Expert Training:Specialized training should be provided to judges and judicial experts to support the assessment and acceptance of complex forms of digital evidence, including zero-knowledge proofs (ZKPs) and verifiable credentials (VCs).
کلیدواژهها English