فصلنامه نوآوری حقوقی

فصلنامه نوآوری حقوقی

سیاست جنایی ایران در قبال خشونت دیجیتالی علیه سلامت روانی زنان با نگاهی بر رویکرد سازمان بهداشت جهانی

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسندگان
1 استاد گروه حقوق کیفری و جرم‌شناسی، مرکز تحقیقات حقوق، واحد مراغه، دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی، مراغه، ایران (نویسندۀ مسئول)
2 دانشجوی دکتری تخصصی گروه حقوق کیفری و جرم‌شناسی، پژوهشگر مرکز تحقیقات حقوق، واحد مراغه، دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی، مراغه، ایران
چکیده
خشونت دیجیتال علیه زنان صرفاً صورت الکترونیکی جرائم سنتی نیست، بلکه به‌واسطۀ ویژگی‌هایی مانند قابلیت تکثیر و بازنشر سریع، ماندگاری داده، ناشناس‌مانی نسبی، امکان دسترسی فرامرزی، ترکیب رفتارهای متعدد در یک فرایند واحد و پیوند آن با سازوکارهای پلتفرمی، می‌تواند دامنه و استمرار آسیب را افزایش دهد. مسئلۀ اصلی پژوهش حاضر آن است که آیا سیاست جنایی ایران، در مواجهه با مصادیقی چون انتشار بدون رضایت تصاویر خصوصی، تحریف و انتشار محتوای تصویری، تهدید و مزاحمت برخط و بهره‌کشی جنسی تسهیل‌شده با فناوری، از ظرفیت لازم برای حمایت مؤثر از سلامت روانی زنان برخوردار است یا خیر. پژوهش با روش توصیفی ـ تحلیلی و رویکرد تطبیقی، نخست مفهوم خشونت دیجیتال را به‌صورت عملیاتی تفکیک می‌کند؛ سپس مقررات کیفری ایران، به‌ویژه مواد ۷۴۴، ۷۴۵ و ۷۴۶ قانون مجازات اسلامی (تعزیرات) و مقررات مرتبط را از منظر عناصر جرم، قلمرو حمایت، قابلیت انطباق با فناوری‌های نوظهور و آثار حمایتی بررسی می‌کند؛ در ادامه، مؤلفه‌های سلامت‌محور مورد تأکید سازمان جهانی بهداشت را به معیارهای قابل سنجش برای ارزیابی سیاست جنایی تبدیل می‌کند. نوآوری مقاله در ارائۀ «مدل سیاست جنایی چهارحلقه‌ای خشونت دیجیتال»است که پاسخ کیفری را در کنار پیشگیری، حمایت سلامت‌محور و حکمرانی/ پاسخ‌گویی نهادی قرار می‌دهد و برای هر حلقه شاخص‌های حقوقی و اجرایی پیشنهاد می‌کند. یافته‌ها نشان می‌دهد که حقوق کیفری ایران در برخی رفتارهای مشخص، ازجمله انتشار غیرمجاز محتوای خصوصی و تحریف تصویر یا صوت، ابزار جرم‌انگاری دارد؛ اما این پوشش، معادل شناسایی جامع خشونت دیجیتال به‌عنوان یک پدیدۀ آسیب‌زا برای سلامت روان نیست. خلأ اصلی نه فقط در فقدان عنوان مجرمانۀ مستقل، بلکه در نبود پیوند نظام‌مند میان جرم‌انگاری، پیشگیری، خدمات سلامت روان، سازوکارهای گزارش‌دهی امن، حذف سریع محتوای زیان‌بار، ثبت داده‌های تفکیک‌شده و ارزیابی اثربخشی سیاست‌هاست. از این ‌رو، مقاله به‌جای توصیۀ کلی به تقویت قوانین، اصلاحات مشخصی را در سه سطح تقنینی، اجرایی و داده‌ای پیشنهاد می‌کند.
کلیدواژه‌ها
موضوعات

عنوان مقاله English

Iran's Criminal Policy Towards Digital Violence Against Women's Mental Health with a Look at the World Health Organization's Approach

نویسندگان English

Jamal Beigi 1
Zahra Eghbali 2
1 Professor, Department of Criminal Law and Criminology, Law Research Center, Maragheh Branch, Islamic Azad University, Maragheh, Iran (Corresponding Author)
2 Ph.D. Student, Department of Criminal Law and Criminology, Researcher at the Law Research Center, Maragheh Branch, Islamic Azad University, Maragheh, Iran
چکیده English

1. Introduction
The rapid growth of digital technologies over the past decade has transformed the traditional structure of human relationships and gender relations and has created new arenas for the manifestation of violence. In this context, women are more exposed than other groups to hidden and overt forms of digital violence; although this violence occurs without physical contact, its profound psychological intensity threatens their psychological security, freedom of expression, self-esteem, and social functioning. This phenomenon has become an emerging crisis, particularly in the post-COVID era and with the increase in dependence on online platforms. In Iran, likewise, statistics on cases related to online harassment, the dissemination of private images, and cyber threats against women are on the rise.
The principal issue addressed by the present study is the existing gap between Iran’s criminal policy approach and global standards. Iran’s criminal policy is primarily focused on penal responses and punishment-oriented measures and pays less attention to preventive mechanisms based on mental health and subsequent support. By contrast, the World Health Organization (WHO), adopting a holistic approach, regards digital violence as part of “gender-based violence” and as a serious threat to public health. The researcher’s principal concern is to examine the extent to which Iran’s current policies are aligned with mental health components and what reforms are necessary to enhance their effectiveness. Accordingly, the present study seeks to answer the following questions: To what extent is Iran’s criminal policy aligned with global standards for combating digital violence, and which mental health components have been overlooked in this policymaking?
2. Research Methodology
The research method adopted in this study is descriptive-analytical. To this end, data concerning Iran’s domestic laws, including the Computer Crimes Law and the Islamic Penal Code, as well as the documents and guidelines of the World Health Organization, have been collected through library-based and documentary research. Subsequently, adopting a comparative approach, the theoretical foundations and operational strategies of both fields have been assessed and evaluated. The analysis focuses on identifying the gap between Iran’s exclusively legal-criminal approach and the WHO’s health-oriented approach.
3. Research Findings
The research findings can be classified under two main headings: “Analysis of Criminological Manifestations” and “Contrast Between Policy Approaches.”
1. Typology of Digital Violence and Its Legal Status in Iran
The analyses indicate that three categories of offenses have posed the greatest threats to women in Iranian cyberspace.
*Pornography and Image Abuse (Revenge Pornography): Under Articles 742 to 746 of the Islamic Penal Code, the dissemination of private images has been criminalized. However, the findings indicate that these offenses are often committed with the aim of infringing reputation and assassinating character, and that women, owing to their gender-specific characteristics, are the principal victims of this phenomenon. Although the current law criminalizes the conduct, it does not pay sufficient attention to the aspects of “structural victimization” or to the remediation of psychological harm resulting from the violation of dignity.
*Cyber Trafficking and Sexual Exploitation: Cyberspace has provided a platform for the “identification,” “recruitment,” and “deception” of women by human trafficking networks. Although the Law on Combating Human Trafficking (2004) exists, establishing the role of digital intermediaries and combating networks that use cryptocurrencies remain challenging.
*Online Harassment and Symbolic Violence: Cyber harassment, approximately 90 percent of which is directed against women, creates an environment filled with anxiety and insecurity. In addition, the study refers to a novel form of violence termed “symbolic violence” or “the imposition of beauty ideals.” Unregulated advertising for cosmetic surgery in Iranian cyberspace places women under psychological pressure to change their bodies, which constitutes harm to public health but has not been expressly criminalized under criminal law [cite: 380–385].
2. The Contrast Between the Health-Oriented Paradigm (WHO) and the Security-Oriented Paradigm (Iran)
The comparative findings indicate that the World Health Organization regards digital violence as an extension of gender-based violence and as a “public health” crisis with consequences such as chronic anxiety, depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). The Organization’s strategy is based on “primary prevention” (education and media literacy), “secondary prevention” (risk screening and psychological intervention), and “tertiary support” (victim empowerment) [cite: 408–412].
In contrast, Iran’s criminal policy is primarily based on the paradigms of “moral security” and “criminalization.” Existing laws focus more on the conduct of the offender than on the psychological condition of the victim. Iran lacks national protocols for the psychological support of victims of cyber violence and does not have a targeted educational system for the prevention of these offenses. This policy gap has resulted in persistently high rates of psychological harm and non-reporting among women, despite police and judicial responses.
4. Conclusion and Recommendations
The present study concluded that Iran’s criminal policy toward digital violence against women, although active in the punitive dimension and in responding to clear manifestations (such as the dissemination of images), has serious gaps in the preventive and supportive dimensions. The current situation indicates the predominance of a one-dimensional penal approach that regards digital violence merely as a security disorder, whereas, according to WHO standards, this phenomenon is a public health problem.
The absence of a precise definition of gender-based cyber violence, the lack of enforcement mechanisms to address symbolic violence (such as harmful beauty advertising), and the absence of a link between the judicial system and the mental health system have been identified as the main challenges. To move beyond the current situation and enhance the effectiveness of criminal policy, the following recommendations are proposed:
1. Integration of Penal Policy and a Health-Oriented Approach: A transition from a purely reactive approach to an approach in which therapeutic and counseling interventions form part of the judicial proceedings. The establishment of psychological service centers specifically for victims of digital violence and the design of a national counseling protocol are necessary.
2. Legal Reforms: The criminalization of emerging forms, such as “gender-based deepfakes” and “beauty-related symbolic violence,” and the legal definition of gender-based digital violence.
3. Social and Educational Prevention: A focus on digital literacy and cyber safety education for women and girls in order to increase psychological resilience, in accordance with WHO recommendations on primary prevention.
4. Development of Supportive Infrastructure: The establishment of safe and confidential reporting systems for vulnerable women and the requirement for domestic platforms to comply with user security standards.
Ultimately, effective criminal policy requires health and mental health institutions, alongside the police and the Judiciary, to play an active role in the process of prevention and treatment so that women’s psychological security in the digital environment is ensured.

کلیدواژه‌ها English

Digital violence
women
mental health
criminal policy
World Health Organization
victim-centered approach
دوره 2، شماره 3
بهار 1405
صفحه 135-174

  • تاریخ دریافت 27 دی 1404
  • تاریخ بازنگری 25 بهمن 1404
  • تاریخ پذیرش 27 اسفند 1404
  • تاریخ اولین انتشار 01 فروردین 1405
  • تاریخ انتشار 01 فروردین 1405