فصلنامه نوآوری حقوقی

فصلنامه نوآوری حقوقی

چالش‌های حقوقی احراز هویت غیرمتمرکز (DID) در نظام اسناد رسمی ایران

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسندگان
1 دانشجوی دکتری، حقوق خصوصی، دانشکدۀ علوم انسانی، واحد یاسوج، دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی ، کهگیلویه و بویر‌احمد ، ایران (نویسنده مسئول)
2 استادیار ، گروه حقوق خصوصی، دانشکدۀ علوم انسانی، واحد یاسوج ، دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی، کهگیلویه و بویر‌احمد، ایران.
3 دکتری حقوق کیفری و جرم‌شناسی، دانشکدۀ حقوق، واحد تهران مرکزی، دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی، تهران، ایران.
چکیده
احراز هویت غیرمتمرکز (DID)، که بر پایۀ فناوری دفترکل توزیع‌شده (DLT) و استانداردهای کنسرسیوم جهانی وب (W3C) نظیر اعتبارات قابل تأیید (VC) توسعه یافته، نویدبخش یک تحول بنیادین در نظام اسناد رسمی و توثیق کشور ایران است. با این حال، اجرای این الگو با چالش‌های حقوقی عمیق و ساختاری مواجه است. این پژوهش با اتخاذ یک رویکرد تحلیلی ـ تطبیقی و مبنایی، ابتدا به تبیین و تحلیل تضاد بنیادین میان اصل حاکمیت هویتی شخص (SSI) به‌عنوان شالودۀ احراز هویت غیرمتمرکز و اصل انحصار حاکمیت دولت در احراز هویت و توثیق اسناد در نظام حقوقی ایران می‌پردازد. این تعارض به‌طور خاص در مادۀ 1287 قانون مدنی و مادۀ ۲۲ قانون ثبت اسناد و املاک متبلور می‌شود. سؤالات محوری تحقیق بر شناسایی دقیق موانع حقوقی و فقهی DID و ارائۀ مدل‌های بومی‌سازی جهت سازگاری آن با فقه شیعه متمرکز است. یافته‌های تحلیل فقهی و حقوقی نشان می‌دهد که الگوی DID، علی‌رغم توانایی در ارتقای کارایی و حفظ حریم خصوصی اشخاص، به‌دلیل عدم انطباق با معیارهای حجیت و توثیق در فقه شیعه و همچنین ساختار قانون‌محور اسناد رسمی، با موانع اساسی روبه‌روست. ازجمله این موانع می‌توان به عدم اعتبار قضائی، ابهام در تعیین مسئولیت حقوقی (به‌ویژه در فرض تقصیر در نگهداری کلید خصوصی، مطابق با مادۀ ۱ قانون مسئولیت مدنی، ۱۳۳۹ و قواعد فقهی اتلاف و تسبیب) و ریسک وابستگی به زیرساخت‌های خارجی در صورت تحریم‌ها (با توجه به تأکید اصل ۱۵۲ قانون اساسی بر حفظ استقلال) اشاره کرد. تحلیل تطبیقی با مدل‌های موفق جهانی نظیر نظام احراز هویت الکترونیکی و خدمات اعتماد در اتحادیۀ اروپا و اقامت الکترونیکی استونی، امکان بومی‌سازی را از طریق طراحی مدل‌های ترکیبی که نقش نهادهای رسمی را در تأیید اولیه هویت حفظ می‌کنند، تأیید می‌نماید. پیشنهادات شامل اصلاح قانون ثبت برای تعریف «امضای غیرمتمرکز رسمی»، ایجاد sandbox نظارتی، آموزش قضات و توسعۀ بلاکچین ملی است.
کلیدواژه‌ها
موضوعات

عنوان مقاله English

Legal Challenges of Decentralized Identity (DID) within Iran’s System of Official Documents.

نویسندگان English

Ali Ahmadi 1
Hamid reza rostami 2
Nazanin Abbaspoorekder 3
1 PhD Student, Private Law, Faculty of Humanities, Yasouj Branch, Islamic Azad University Kohgiluyeh and Boyer-Ahmad, Iran (Corresponding Author)
2 Assistant Professor , Department of Private Law, Faculty of Humanities, Islamic Azad University Kohgiluyeh and Boyer-Ahmad, Iran.
3 Ph.D in Criminal Law and Criminology, Faculty of Law, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.
چکیده English

The rapid development of Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT) and the emergence of Decentralized Identity (DID) and Self-Sovereign Identity (SSI) have fundamentally transformed contemporary approaches to digital identity management. Unlike traditional identity systems, which rely on centralized governmental authorities or trusted intermediaries, DID architectures enable individuals to control their own digital identifiers through cryptographic mechanisms while minimizing dependence on centralized identity providers. The World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) formally recognizes DIDs as decentralized, cryptographically verifiable identifiers designed to operate independently of centralized registries and certificate authorities. While decentralized identity offers significant advantages in terms of privacy, interoperability, selective disclosure, and user autonomy, its adoption poses substantial legal challenges for jurisdictions whose legal systems remain grounded in centralized authentication and state-controlled documentary evidence. In Iran, the legal validity of official documents is fundamentally linked to governmental authentication. Article 1287 of the Civil Code recognizes official instruments only when executed before competent public authorities, while Article 22 of the Law on the Registration of Deeds and Real Estate grants conclusive legal recognition to registered ownership. Consequently, the decentralized logic underlying DID conflicts with the traditional legal architecture governing official documentation and evidentiary authority. Against this background, the present study critically examines the legal and jurisprudential implications of implementing decentralized identity within Iran's legal system. It investigates three principal questions: (i) whether DID is compatible with the existing statutory framework governing official documents and electronic transactions; (ii) whether decentralized identity can be reconciled with the principles of Ja'fari (Imamiyyah) jurisprudence and constitutional requirements concerning national sovereignty; and (iii) which legislative and institutional reforms are necessary to facilitate the localized adoption of DID while preserving legal certainty and governmental authority. The study argues that although decentralized identity introduces substantial technological advantages, its implementation within Iran requires a hybrid governance model that preserves sovereign identity attestation while incorporating internationally recognized decentralized identity standards.
Methodology
This research adopts a descriptive–analytical, doctrinal, and comparative legal methodology.
Primary legal sources include the Iranian Civil Code, the Law on the Registration of Deeds and Real Estate, the Electronic Commerce Act, civil liability legislation, cybercrime legislation, and constitutional provisions. These sources are analyzed alongside relevant principles of Imamiyyah jurisprudence concerning evidentiary authority (ḥujjiyyah), documentary proof (bayyinah), liability (itlāf and tasbīb), preservation of public order (ḥifẓ al-niẓām), and governmental authority. The comparative component examines internationally recognized technical standards developed by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) together with selected digital identity frameworks, including the European Union's eIDAS framework and Estonia's digital identity model, in order to identify regulatory approaches that may be adapted to Iran's legal and constitutional environment. International experience increasingly demonstrates that decentralized identity can coexist with governmental trust frameworks through hybrid identity architectures rather than complete decentralization.
Findings
The analysis demonstrates that decentralized identity presents several fundamental legal and jurisprudential challenges within Iran's existing system of official documentation. First, DID is difficult to reconcile with the statutory concept of the official instrument under Article 1287 of the Civil Code. Because decentralized identifiers are created and controlled through cryptographic keys rather than authenticated by public officials, documents generated within DID ecosystems lack the governmental certification traditionally required for official documentary status. Consequently, such documents would most likely be treated as ordinary private documents under current Iranian law.
Second, decentralized identity creates significant uncertainty regarding civil and criminal liability. In distributed digital environments involving users, credential issuers, blockchain operators, software developers, and governmental institutions, identifying the legally responsible party following security breaches, identity theft, or cryptographic key compromise becomes considerably more complex than under conventional centralized identity systems. Third, reliance upon international decentralized identity standards raises concerns regarding technological sovereignty. Dependence on foreign technical infrastructures, international blockchain networks, or externally governed standards may conflict with constitutional principles emphasizing national independence and secure governmental control over critical digital infrastructure. These concerns support the development of domestically governed digital identity infrastructures capable of maintaining technological autonomy while preserving international interoperability. Fourth, important jurisprudential questions remain unresolved. Traditional Shiite jurisprudence recognizes documentary evidence largely through legally recognized testimony, governmental authentication, and established evidentiary principles. Cryptographic authentication based solely upon decentralized trust mechanisms therefore requires either expanded jurisprudential interpretation or new authoritative legal opinions recognizing advanced digital authentication methods within the broader objectives of preserving public order and protecting individual rights. Finally, comparative analysis indicates that complete decentralization is neither necessary nor desirable in highly regulated legal systems. International experience increasingly favors hybrid identity governance, whereby decentralized identifiers operate alongside trusted governmental institutions responsible for initial identity verification and the issuance of verifiable credentials. Such models preserve both technological innovation and legal certainty.
Conclusion and Policy Recommendations
The study concludes that decentralized identity introduces a fundamental shift from state-centered identity management toward user-controlled digital identity. Although this transition presents important opportunities for enhancing privacy, data minimization, interoperability, and digital autonomy, it simultaneously challenges the centralized legal foundations governing official documents within Iran. The analysis demonstrates that these challenges are not insurmountable. Rather than replacing governmental authority, decentralized identity should be integrated through a hybrid legal framework that combines sovereign identity verification with decentralized credential management. Such an approach would preserve the evidentiary authority of official documents while benefiting from the technological advantages of decentralized identity systems. To facilitate this transition, several legislative and institutional reforms are proposed. First, the Registration Law should be amended to recognize official digital instruments and official decentralized signatures based upon verifiable credentials issued under governmental supervision. Second, a statutory liability framework should allocate responsibility among identity holders, credential issuers, verification service providers, and governmental authorities according to their respective roles within decentralized identity ecosystems. Third, a nationally governed blockchain infrastructure should be established to support domestically issued decentralized identifiers while ensuring compliance with constitutional requirements concerning national sovereignty and resilience against external technological dependencies. Fourth, a regulatory sandbox should be created to enable controlled experimentation with DID-based authentication and registration services before nationwide implementation. Finally, specialized judicial education should strengthen the capacity of judges, forensic experts, and legal practitioners to evaluate advanced forms of digital evidence, including Verifiable Credentials (VCs) and Zero-Knowledge Proofs (ZKPs), thereby improving the effective administration of justice in emerging digital environments. Overall, the study demonstrates that the successful localization of decentralized identity within Iran depends not upon abandoning the traditional legal framework but upon developing a coherent hybrid model that reconciles technological decentralization with legal certainty, constitutional principles, and the jurisprudential foundations of Imamiyyah law.

کلیدواژه‌ها English

Decentralized Identity (DID)
Self-Sovereign Identity (SSI)
distributed ledger technology
official documents
digital identity
Iranian law
Imamiyyah jurisprudence
verifiable credentials
legal informatics
دوره 1، شماره 2
زمستان 1404
صفحه 139-173

  • تاریخ دریافت 17 مهر 1404
  • تاریخ پذیرش 26 آبان 1404
  • تاریخ اولین انتشار 01 دی 1404
  • تاریخ انتشار 01 دی 1404